Report this comment
  • "The truth is that comparing the provision of a defibrillator with financing a legal challenge to prevent a potentially toxic incinerator being erected in our town is an invidious exercise. Both are justifiable for different reasons.

    I am not qualified to make a detailed case for a defibrillator but what I do say, with absolute certainty, is that it is a scandal that CWAC Council seems intent on abandoning the people of Northwich by not joining forces with local people and their campaign groups, CHAIN and SID, in using the legal process.

    This is a criticism is of the Council itself, its leadership and officers, not of individual councillors such as Malcolm Byram and Norman Wright.

    If Cheshire East Council had taken the same attitude as CWAC, the builders would have already started digging the foundations for an incinerator in Middlewich.

    It is no coincidence that the QC that CHAIN wants to use to put the case for Northwich is the one who successfully represented Middlewich.

    The case against the incinerator has been made very often and I will not repeat it here other than to categorically assert that there is nowhere else on the planet where a waste incinerator of the size intended for Northwich, burning 150,000lbs of garbage every single hour, is situated so close to a residential area and urban centre. In effect, the community would become the subjects of a grotesque experiment to see what happens when you build a mega waste incinerator close the centre of a town.

    Nobody knows with any degree of certainty what the consequences of that would be on the heath of local children who would have to endure it year after year. Surely the Council does not need more evidence to justify taking up the one last chance to stop it happening."
  • This field is mandatory
  • This field is mandatory
  • Please note we will not accept reports with HTML tags or URLs in them.


  • Enter the above word in the box below

Please be fair, courteous and respectful to the views of others so we can build a vibrant community in a safe online environment. You are personal liable for your comments and action will be taken against anyone who offends, ridicules or posts malicious and damaging views. If you wish to complain, please contact us.

Money will either buy defibrillator or fight incinerator for Northwich

Some Cheshire West and Chester Council (CWAC) members have agreed to donate cash from their members’ budgets to challenge Government approval for a waste plant in Lostock Some Cheshire West and Chester Council (CWAC) members have agreed to donate cash from their members’ budgets to challenge Government approval for a waste plant in Lostock

A LIFESAVING defibrillator will be given to residents of a Northwich village if councillors do not help fund a legal battle.

Some Cheshire West and Chester Council (CWAC) members have agreed to donate cash from their members’ budgets to challenge Government approval for a waste plant in Lostock.

But if this does not go ahead, CWAC councillors for Marbury want to buy Barnton a defibrillator.

Clrs Malcolm Byram and Norman Wright, who represent the Marbury ward alongside Clr Don Hammond, explained the situation at the latest Barnton Parish Council meeting.

“We’ve agreed to support a defibrillator in Great Budworth and we’re looking at one in Barnton,” Clr Byram said.

“The cost is from £700 to £1,200 and I would suggest that eventually you would want two.”

Clr Wright said: “It all depends on the Tata inquiry and whether we are going to fund that or not.”

Cheshire Anti Incinerator Network (CHAIN) has been leading the campaign against plans for an energy from waste plant in Griffiths Road, submitted by Tata Chemicals Europe and E.ON.

These proposals were initially rejected by CWAC but then given the go-ahead by the Government in October, following a public inquiry.

After taking legal advice, CWAC decided not to challenge this result as a body, prompting CHAIN to seek its own advice from QC Anthony Crean.

After being informed it had a ‘strong case’ CHAIN started to fundraise for a judicial review and appealed for CWAC members to donate some of their individual £10,000 members’ budgets, which are to be spent on worthy local projects.

The aim of a village defibrillator would be for it to be publicly accessible at all times.

Local Businesses

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree